Government climate advisers have urged ministers not to weaken the ZEV mandate, insisting electric car sales are growing fast enough to meet existing targets and warning that relaxing the rules could damage British manufacturing.
The Climate Change Committee (CCC) has written to transport secretary Heidi Alexander calling for the current electric vehicle sales targets to remain in place until 2030.
It argues that the mandate is working effectively and says watering it down could increase motoring costs, leave the UK more exposed to volatile oil prices and threaten the country’s climate commitments.
The intervention comes as speculation continues that the government intends to announce changes to the mandate, reducing targets.
The government insists that no decision has been made.
Industry groups such as the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT) have called for an ‘urgent’ review of the mandate, and welcomed ministers’ consultation of the policy.
In a letter dated November 18, CCC chairman Nigel Topping argues that electric car sales are already growing quickly enough to meet the mandate’s requirements once the various compliance flexibilities available to manufacturers are taken into account.
Although the headline ZEV target for 2026 is 33%, the CCC says manufacturers effectively need to achieve around 25% electric sales after accounting for CO2 flexibilities.
Battery-electric cars accounted for 27% of new car registrations in the first 10 months of the year, rising to 32% in October.
The committee believes these figures demonstrate that the transition is progressing at the required pace.
In response, SMMT chief executive Mike Hawes said: The CCC, however, ignores the damaging cost of the targets it defends: billions in unsustainable discounts and millions more in government incentives, yet even with sky high fuel prices, fewer than three in ten drivers will switch this year.
‘The industry cannot subsidise the transition indefinitely, which is why it is unified in seeking change.’
Changing ZEV will damage industry
The CCC’s letter also claims weakening the mandate could leave the UK more dependent on imported oil, with some of the government’s proposed changes potentially increasing consumption by the equivalent of 15 million barrels annually by 2030.
At October 2026 oil prices, the CCC estimates that would cost the country around £1.3bn a year.
The committee further argues that a typical household with access to home charging could save more than £800 annually by switching from a petrol car to an EV.
However, its own analysis acknowledges that households without home charging could still face around £100 in additional annual costs.
The CCC also believes the mandate is helping to protect the future of British car manufacturing.
It points out that 77% of British-built cars were exported in September and argues that manufacturers must remain competitive as overseas markets increasingly switch to electric vehicles.
The committee says weakening the rules could create uncertainty for manufacturers that have already committed billions of pounds to electrification.
It also wants changes to the treatment of plug-in hybrids under the mandate.
The CCC argues that existing rules give manufacturers excessive credit for selling PHEVs because official emissions calculations do not accurately reflect real-world fuel consumption.
It also claims the system gives newer manufacturers, particularly Chinese brands, an advantage by allowing them to generate additional compliance credits against historic industry emissions averages.
Rather than weaken the overall targets, the committee wants ministers to tighten these rules and provide more support for electric van adoption and affordable public charging.
Hawes insisted that the industry’s commitment to electrification was not in doubt but argued that sales targets should reflect consumer demand.
He added: ‘Manufacturers’ commitment is not in question: new models with ever-better performance and lower costs will keep coming and sales will rise, mandate or not.
‘But the pace should be market-driven – and it is worth noting that no major global market ahead of the UK has a mandate.’
The SMMT also disputed the CCC’s suggestion that the mandate was supporting domestic manufacturing investment.
Hawes said: ‘Contrary to the CCC’s claims, the Mandate is deterring local investment as however much manufacturers export, without a strong local market there is no business case to build here.’
Meanwhile, Polestar UK has backed the CCC’s position, warning that major changes to the mandate could undermine investment in electric vehicles.
Managing director Matt Galvin said: ‘The ZEV mandate is fundamental to this transition. It is driving investment and innovation, accelerating the industry’s shift away from petrol and diesel.
‘We are approaching a historic tipping point, as more drivers discover the benefits of electric motoring, including running costs as low as 3p per mile.’
Galvin warned that weakening the rules could penalise manufacturers that had already invested heavily in electric technology.
He added: ‘There is room to debate the pace of the transition, but there must be no retreat from the destination.
‘Moving the goalposts dramatically at this stage would undermine investor confidence, penalise manufacturers that have committed to electrification and leave British drivers with fewer models, less choice, and potentially higher prices.’
He concluded: ‘The industry needs long-term certainty to invest, innovate and compete. My message to ministers is simple: progress, not postponement.’
