A Scottish used car dealer has been allowed to keep trading after a customer dispute threatened the future of the business.
Colin Macdonald, who runs Irvine Car Centre in Ayrshire, has been allowed to renew his second-hand dealer’s licence after an objection from an irate customer was overruled.
Local motorist Tom Dawson challenged the renewal at a meeting of North Ayrshire Licensing Board last Wednesday (November 18), claiming the dealership had sold him a faulty vehicle and failed to address his concerns.
The dispute centred on an 11-year-old Nissan Qashqai Dawson that Dawson bought from the business earlier this year.
Macdonald told the committee he had agreed to have the car MOT tested before collection and sent it to an independent testing station on March 17.
It failed on suspension arms, dropped light bulbs and wiper blades, with the necessary repairs carried out before it passed a retest without advisories.
Dawson then collected the car a few days later before subsequently reporting a slow puncture, which the dealership arranged to have repaired.
However, within weeks of that issue being resolved, the buyer also reported warning lights on the dashboard. Macdonald said the business supplied a replacement battery under warranty, which resolved the issue.
Despite this, a further disagreement emerged three months later when Dawson complained about a broken coil spring.
After consulting North Ayrshire Trading Standards, the car dealer argued that the problem was a wear-and-tear issue and that the customer had covered 1,600 miles since taking the vehicle.
Dawson disputed this and said an independent inspection had identified several additional problems which, in the inspector’s opinion, had existed before the vehicle was sold.
He also claimed the dealership had ignored his request to inspect the car.
Speaking to the committee, Dawson said: ‘My objection is based on the quality of the vehicle I received and the service I received post sale.’
Macdonald maintained that the dealership was not responsible for the broken spring, adding that it would cost around £30 to repair.
He also defended his record, telling councillors he had been trading for 36 years, had sold thousands of cars and had never previously faced an objection to his licence renewal.
‘One disgruntled customer who is not happy with a road spring breaking on a 10-year-old car three months after purchase does not make someone who is not fit and proper to hold a licence,’ he said.
Licensing committee chair Collier said members had considered both sides of the dispute but concluded that the disagreement over the vehicle was a civil matter and not relevant to whether Macdonald should retain his licence.
The committee agreed to grant the renewal, although Macdonald was warned that further similar complaints could result in him being called back before the board.
Cllr Christina Larsen proposed granting the application, with the motion seconded by Cllr Ronnie Stalker.
The case was first reported by the Daily Record.
The case once again brings the Consumer Rights Act under the spotlight, following repeated complaints from car dealers.
Earlier this year, retailers named the Consumer Rights Act as the one thing they would most like to see the government change to support the motor trade.
Speaking exclusively to Car Dealer, retailers called for the introduction of a US-style ‘Lemon Law’ that splits cover by mileage and is explicit in which parts are included.
A government spokesman later told Car Dealer: ‘Our consumer rights legislation helps people buy with confidence, while providing clear protections when things go wrong.
‘We are always working with business to hear how regulations operate in practice while also supporting them through our Small Business Plan.’

