A used car dealer who bagged more than £40,000 via a series of consumer protection offences has been ordered to repay just £10 or face a day in jail.
John Minnis was one of two directors of neighbouring Warrington businesses Car Nation and Nation Motors, which left 11 customers out of pocket following a series of complaints between March and December 2023.
Minnis and fellow director Anthony Miller admitted misleading customers over second-hand car sales, after an investigation revealed they had been taking deposits under false pretences, not delivering cars as promised and misleading buyers over service histories.
Customers also had their telephone numbers blocked when trying to contact the businesses, while others were left chasing refunds well into 2024.
Miller was the sole director of Car Nation (NW) Ltd and pleaded guilty to eight offences under the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008.
These included breaching professional diligence standards over a 16-month period involving 10 customers, alongside seven misleading actions relating to used car sales.
Minnis was the sole director of Nation Motors Ltd, which received money from sales and other business transactions before distributing it to Car Nation and other businesses.
He admitted three offences under the same regulations, including breaching professional diligence standards, misleading a customer and using aggressive practices towards someone buying a second-hand car.
Both men were sentenced at Liverpool Crown Court in March, with Miller receiving a 20-month prison sentence suspended for 18 months.
He was also ordered to complete 250 hours of unpaid community work and banned from acting as a company director for four years.
Minnis received an immediate six-month prison sentence, to run concurrently with a custodial sentence he was already serving.
Now, the duo have returned to Liverpool Crown Court, where a hearing under the Proceeds of Crime Act sought to establish how much money could be confiscated from the former directors.
The court heard that Minnis was found to have benefited from £42,456.65, but the court ordered him to repay just £10 following a review of his financial circumstances.
He faces a prison term of just one-day if he fails to pay by January 15, the Warrington Guardian reports.
Meanwhile, Miller was found to have benefited by the same amount but ordered to repay the full amount by the same deadline.
He faces a default prison term of 15 months if he fails to pay.
During the original sentencing, the judge described the misconduct as ‘systemic’.
Councillor John Kerr-Brown, cabinet member for housing services and licensing at Warrington Borough Council , said: ‘This case shows very clearly the harm that dishonest business practices can inflict on ordinary people.
‘The victims suffered financial loss, emotional distress and months of frustration simply trying to get basic answers from the companies.
‘This demonstrates our commitment to taking firm action against any business that seeks to exploit consumers.’
The two businesses, which operated next to each other near Warrington town centre, have both been wound up since the offences.

