Alfa Romeo GiuliettaAlfa Romeo Giulietta


Advertising watchdog reverses ruling to uphold complaint against Glyn Hopkin and Fiat Chrysler Automobiles UK

Time 10:36 am, October 26, 2017

THE Advertising Standards Authority has reversed a ruling it made earlier this year that saw a complaint against Glyn Hopkin and Fiat Chrysler Automobiles UK rejected.

As reported by Car Dealer at the time, the watchdog investigated a complaint about two adverts for Alfa Romeo Giulietta vehicles, similar to the one pictured, in Chelmsford and Romford that appeared on the website on May 13, 2016. The complainant said they understood the two vehicles to be ex-fleet and challenged whether the adverts omitted information that could have affected their pricing – specifically, whether the cars would have had multiple users.

After submissions by Glyn Hopkin and Fiat Chrysler Automobiles UK (FCA), including one from FCA saying its records for the cars showed that one vehicle was used by a self-employed FCA contractor to provide technical training on the car and the other was used by a member of its own staff, so neither had had multiple users, the ASA said it considered that no material information was omitted. It concluded that the adverts weren’t misleading and didn’t uphold the complaint, adding that no further action was needed.

However, in a rare move by the authority, it has now done a U-turn on the ruling, saying it considered that vehicles previously leased out for business purposes and used by multiple users were more likely to have been subjected to wear and tear compared with vehicles previously owned by a private owner.

It said that with regard to one of the adverts, information that indicated the car was ex-fleet, having been used for business purposes, which it considered consumers needed to know about to make an informed decision before buying it had been omitted. Meanwhile, the other advert didn’t state that the car had previously been used for business purposes, which again the ASA considered was material information that consumers needed to know to make an informed decision before buying it.

As such, it said that both adverts were misleading. It has now ordered both Glyn Hopkin and FCA to ensure that future ads don’t mislead potential buyers by leaving out such information.

MORE: Advertising Standards Authority rules in favour of Glyn Hopkin over Alfa Romeo adverts

MORE: Alpine A110 tweet ‘glamorised and promoted dangerous driving’, says advertising watchdog

MORE: BMW advert banned for making speed ‘the main message’

On Lamborghini Aventador is turned into the world’s most expensive racing sim

Car Dealer Magazine's avatar

Car Dealer has been covering the motor trade since 2008 as both a print and digital publication. In 2020 the title went fully digital and now provides daily motoring updates on this website for the car industry. A digital magazine is published once a month.

More stories...

Server 108