• Car Dealer Plus
No Result
View All Result
  • Latest
  • Used Cars
  • Live
  • Forum
  • Power 2020
  • Used Car Awards
  • CDX
  • Knowledge
  • Suppliers Guide
  • About Us
  • Latest Issue
  • Top 100
  • CD Plus
  • Latest
  • Used Cars
  • Live
  • Forum
  • Power 2020
  • Used Car Awards
  • CDX
  • Knowledge
  • Suppliers Guide
  • About Us
  • Latest Issue
  • Top 100
  • CD Plus
No Result
View All Result

GAP insurance intervention by FCA fails to have as big an impact as expected

Car Dealer Magazine by Car Dealer Magazine
August 15, 2018
0
Home News

ACTION on GAP insurance sales has failed to make the hoped-for impact, a report by the Financial Conduct Authority has shown.  

In 2014, the regulator said it had found evidence of ‘consumer harm’ in the GAP insurance market, with an overpayment for add-on GAP insurance of around £76m to £121m a year out of an estimated market size of £152m, and an average claims ratio that was much lower than for other general insurance products.

The FCA said there were four factors:

• Vehicle sellers enjoying a strong point-of-sale competitive advantage, meaning there was little or no pressure on sellers to lower the price
• A lack of information, including about alternative providers, preventing consumers from being able to compare products
• Many consumers not knowing that they could buy GAP insurance separately (‘standalone’) elsewhere, often at a lower price
• Consumers’ focus on the main product  – ie, the vehicle – leading to many buying add-on GAP insurance when they may not have wanted and/or needed it, with the add-on mechanism weakening consumers’ decision-making and engagement

It therefore intervened in September 2015, making it mandatory for vehicle sellers to provide sufficient information to consumers and bringing in a two-day cooling-off period during the sale process.

The authority said it believed that having more time and information would mean consumers could decide if they needed GAP insurance and could shop around.

As such, the FCA expected improved competition between add-on and standalone sellers, with standalone sales increasing relative to add-on sales, and better outcomes for the consumer, namely better-informed and more active decision-making during the purchasing process, including more consumers shopping around and buying GAP insurance from standalone providers, as well as an overall decrease in add-on GAP insurance sales, since it was concerned about consumers buying potentially unsuitable add-on products.

However, it has had to admit that although its intervention ‘has helped to reduce considerable harm in the market’, it was actually less than expected. A total of 41 firms and 1,000 consumers were involved in the study, and add-on sales were found to be 16 to 23 per cent lower when up to 32.5 per cent had been predicted, while the standalone market share had risen by just eight per cent from six per cent pre-intervention, although an increase of up to 40 per cent was expected.

Meanwhile, add-on prices were two to three per cent lower but a drop of up to 17 per cent had been predicted. In addition, the price differential with standalone had increased when it should have narrowed.

The FCA concluded that its intervention had had a greater impact on sales than on prices, while its survey of consumers ‘overstated the impact of the intervention on switching to the standalone market, and underestimated the number of consumers who would make a more considered purchase given the information and time to do so’.

Pictured at top is the entrance to the FCA’s offices in London

MORE: RAC Dealer Network to launch five-star Defaqto GAP insurance cover

MORE: Guest blog – The growth of GAP insurance

MORE: Financial watchdog launches probe into car loans provider

Related Posts

Supercar graphic
News

Moving on up: Here are the top 10 used supercars to buy if you want to see a return on your investment

February 26, 2021
Subaru sign via Newspress
News

Subaru adds three dealers to network with plans for at least 15 as part of restructure that will see 10 leave

February 26, 2021
G3 Motorhouse in Failsworth from Google
News

Car dealers must pay out thousands after Trading Standards investigation found they’d clocked cars

February 26, 2021
Mike Hawes
News

SMMT calls for dealers to open ‘ideally before April 12’ as car production levels slump to 12-year low

February 26, 2021
Online car sales on an iPad
News

Fifth of car buyers think online sales will overtake those in showrooms by 2025 – but many think it’ll never happen

February 26, 2021
The Volkswagen Tiguan R on the road
News

Feb 26 round-up: Smart motorway investigation; Queen says get jab; Twitter’s ‘Super Follows’ feature; Tiguan R on sale

February 26, 2021

Want the latest news?

Sign up to Car Dealer's daily news email updates

Subscribe
How many car dealerships does each manufacturer have in the UK? Car Dealerships Locations List 2021 revealed
News

How many car dealerships does each manufacturer have in the UK? Car Dealerships Locations List 2021 revealed

February 24, 2021
Used Car Awards with Mike Brewer and James Baggott graphi
News

Who won what at the Used Car Awards 2020? Mike Brewer reveals our winning car dealers

February 11, 2021
Car Dealer issue 156 front cover and Used Car Awards
Online Magazine

Out now: Car Dealer issue 156 features our Used Car Awards, H.R. Owen CEO Ken Choo and lots more

February 23, 2021
Used car market stronger than ever as August sees sales up by nearly 50 per cent for Big Motoring World
News

Opinion: Here are 10 reasons why I think there’ll be a rapid recovery in car sales when lockdown ends

February 16, 2021
Trophy Cars forecourt
News

Investigation: Meet the hyper-specialist car dealers making their money from weird and wonderful motors

February 11, 2021
Become a Car Dealer Plus member and get more out of this website including free legal advice
News

Become a Car Dealer Plus member and get more out of this website including free legal advice

January 15, 2021
Car Dealer Top 100 – The list in full of the most profitable car dealers in the UK
Car Dealer Top 100

Car Dealer Top 100 – The list in full of the most profitable car dealers in the UK

February 10, 2021
Bitcoin ATM terminal
News

Will car dealers in the UK accept Bitcoin for payment? Dealers speak out after Tesla plans to accept cryptocurrency 

February 18, 2021
  • Latest
  • Used Cars
  • Live
  • Forum
  • Power 2020
  • Used Car Awards
  • CDX
  • Knowledge
  • Suppliers Guide
  • About Us
  • Latest Issue
  • Top 100
  • CD Plus
Call us: 020 8125 3880

© 2020 Blackball Media

No Result
View All Result
  • Car Dealer Plus
  • Latest
  • Used Cars
  • Live
  • Forum
  • Power 2020
  • Used Car Awards
  • CDX
  • Knowledge
  • Suppliers Guide
  • About Us
  • Latest Issue
  • Top 100

© 2020 Blackball Media

Log In
Register
Register
Server C