Just Toys Classic CarsJust Toys Classic Cars


Classic car dealers charged with stealing £488,000 from customers who never received payment for vehicles

  • Just Toys Classic Cars owners were charged with grand theft in April
  • A report has concluded they ‘had no intention’ of paying victims
  • Losses total $614,000 from 20 customers

Time 9:35 am, May 1, 2022

Following years of campaigning, customers of an American classic car dealer who ran off with their money are finally seeing them charged.

The economic crimes detectives investigative documents reveal a total of 20 victims, 21 vehicles and losses totalling $614,000 (£488,345).

The father and son owners Michael Smith Snr and Michael Smith Jr were charged in April with grand theft but have been released since been released on bond. They face up to 30 years in prison.

Just Toys Classic Cars from Orlando, Florida, is accused of taking cars on consignment from customers promising payment in 60 days but many say they never received the proceeds of the sale.

They were given various excuses for why they had not received the money and were often told their car was ‘sold or about to be sold’ when they chased the company.

Detectives say 20 different customers had money stolen from them over the three years.

According to WESH news channel, the complaint concluded that the dealership had ‘no intention of ever providing payment to the victims’.

The business was shut down by authorities in 2019, three years after the first thefts were reported to have happened.

WFTV9 investigated the accusations at the time and found more than 20 customers who had their cars sold but received no cash.

In 2019, one customer of Just Toys Classic Cars, Ben Kreider, told WFTV9: ‘I don’t know where the vehicle is and, obviously, we don’t have any money.’

Just Toys Classic Cars had sold Kreider’s family’s 2002 Camaro on consignment eight months before for $28,000 and he didn’t receive any of the money.

Rebecca Chaplin's avatar

Rebecca has been a motoring and business journalist since 2014, previously writing and presenting for titles such as the Press Association, Auto Express and Car Buyer. She has worked in many roles for Car Dealer Magazine’s publisher Blackball Media including head of editorial.

More stories...

Server 108